❴Reading❵ ➹ Keaton: The Man Who Wouldn't Lie Down Author Tom Dardis – Saudionline.co.uk



10 thoughts on “Keaton: The Man Who Wouldn't Lie Down

  1. says:

    Buster Keaton, I think, is THE major artist of the 20th Century He s an artist who was totally intuned with the enviornment, whatever it was a violent storm or a machine of some sort He sort of placed his feet to the ground and is taken up by whatever is around him Keaton s face is extremely beautiful It s beautiful because it shows indifference to the horrors of the world I have the complete collection of his major works including the short films and every frame of these films are pure in its naked approach to how one sees the world In many ways he is like a child coming to terms with the world He s hysterical of course, but there are scenes that also makes me cry.This is a very good bio on a great artist PERIOD


  2. says:

    Buster Keaton s life follows a similar curve to that of Charlie Chaplin, though never in quite the same way There is trauma and vaudeville in childhood, a few years of excelling in early films, until the artist is recognised and indulged.There follows a short period of Golden Era each is completely in charge of their own films, creating every aspect, and making films that are still regarded as masterpieces 80 years on.This period is exceptional, in both lives For In Our Hospitality, The Navigator and The General, Buster Keaton has complete control of every shot He writes as he shoots, directs as he acts, and frequently risks his life This singularity of vision, unmatched anywhere outside of an author s relationship with a novel and even then is what pushes these films into greatness.The fall happens to them both in different ways Chaplin, having cashed in, spends the rest of his life trying to be accepted by critics Keaton, who always had a esoteric, less monied appeal, cannot afford such a luxury, and is forced to become a studio man then a bit part man then a gag writer.The fundamental difference between the two, that made Chaplin the succesful and Keaton by far my preferred choice, is simple Chaplin was a comedian who wanted to be an artist Keaton was an artist who wanted to be a comedian.Chaplin always had popular appeal, but his pretentions could never be truly fulfilled his story ends, career wise, with him still coming down from that long ago peak Keaton always made a unique and timeless product, but his aspirations were harder to fill when he had to compromise on method, for reasons of economy read shortsighted studios.Buster s lifegraph does turn up again at the end, as he is rediscovered and critically hailed He cannot return to that Golden Era of film making, but that same Era is now, looking back, eminently justified.


  3. says:

    Where Rudi Blesh s book was a rather serious and kind treatment of Keaton, Dardis book dabbles in the gossipy and inevitably idol tarnishing parts of the man s life the disastrous Talmadge marriage, the equally disastrous Mae Scrivens marriage, the rock bottom alcoholism and affairs I didn t mind the bits of trash, since Keaton was far from perfect In fact, while Blesh s book gave me respect for Keaton the artist, Dardis made me sympathize with Keaton the man.Parts of Keaton s life read like a trainwreck, and Dardis does a far better job of balancing his treatment of Keaton than other authors like Marion Meade.


  4. says:

    This was everything I wanted to know and feel about BK I read it in the summer of 83 And then read it again after I finished it First and last time I have ever done that Since then I have watched Buster s films over and over with the same passion.


  5. says:

    This book sold me on the genius of Buser Keaton, which I had missed until then.Highly recommended.


  6. says:

    The one book to read if you want to know about Buster Keaton.


  7. says:

    OK, I have finished reading every Buster Keaton bio And it turns out this is probably the best one Also, way to link up the fatalistic philosophies of Keaton and Werner Herzog Wheeeeeee


  8. says:

    Inaccurate he awkwardly tries to make Buster Keaton into a sad clown character


  9. says:

    My favorite comedian, but definitely not my favorite book Poorly written


  10. says:

    I love Buster Keaton I enjoy Keaton than Chaplin Not that I have anything against Charlie, but Keaton makes me laugh This book is funny in the beginning, depressing in the middle, and inspiring at the end Buster had a hard life beaten by his dad, taken advantage of by numerous women and hangers on, and addicted to alcohol Through it all, he kept trying to work and once he beat the alcohol mostly , his final act was filled with work which brought him joy, if not the same level of fame he enjoyed in his earlier life In response to an interviewer s question about how he felt about his smashed career and all the bad things that had gone with it, Buster s answer was unhesitating I ve had a very interesting career I have no complaints I think he meant it Chapter 11, page 266.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Keaton: The Man Who Wouldn't Lie Down download Keaton: The Man Who Wouldn't Lie Down, read online Keaton: The Man Who Wouldn't Lie Down, kindle ebook Keaton: The Man Who Wouldn't Lie Down, Keaton: The Man Who Wouldn't Lie Down 985b108f8215 The Definitive Life I Don T Think It Will Ever Be Superseded It Is Scholarly Yet Readable, The Fullest, Most Objective And Factually Detailed Book On Virtually Every Aspect Of Buster S Career And Personality Artistic, Financial, And Pyschological Full Of The Most Interesting And Surprising Information Dwight MacDonald, The New York Review Of Books A Candid Yet Compassionate Account Of Keaton S Turbulent Personal Lifereveals The Roots Of His Humanity His Pessimism His Superb Spirit Of Comic Gloom Boston Globe