❮Reading❯ ➿ I Was Anastasia Author Ariel Lawhon – Saudionline.co.uk

10 thoughts on “I Was Anastasia

  1. says:

    I am Anastasia by Ariel Lawhon is a 2018 Doubleday publication No matter how many movies, documentaries, or books I ve watched or read, the romantic in me simply can t resist the fascination and the mystery of Anastasia Romanov This book examines the life of Anna Anderson, who claimed she was Anastasia, while also chronicling the period of time the Romanov s were in exile, leading up to their execution during the Bolshevik Revolution Anna s claims captured our imaginations for decades and sparked many debates over the legitimacy of her pronouncement While she was often met with skepticism, she also had many staunch supporters I, for one, always loved the notion surrounding this legend I hoped, no matter how far fetched or doubtful the probability, that Anna Anderson really was Anastasia Romanov If a miracle did happen, and Anastasia somehow managed to survive, we could all rationalize our fascination with the Czar s daughter, from Ingrid Bergman s oscar winning portrayal, to the animated Disney film, and all points in between But, of course, the reality is far serious and grim.This novel is obviously a very ambitious undertaking Giving voice to Anastasia, and Anna Anderson, describing minute historical details, adding authentic and vivid dialogue, along with solid pacing, and well drawn characterizations This story is very interesting, and the author certainly did her homework, doing a great job of laying out Anna s complexities Anna was difficult, but also lived with a host of mental issues, making her a sympathetic figure on occasion, which left me with conflicting emotions I often wondered how other people who have read this book felt about her in the end However, I must address the elephant in the room when it comes to the way the author structured the novel She explains the method to her madness in a note at the end of the book, and it does make sense, from the viewpoint of the writer, and logically, I see where she s coming from However, the backwards forwards, first and third person narratives made the book difficult to read than need be, in my opinion I did struggle with the format, I must say However, others may not be bothered by it at all, and may even benefit from it I m not always the sharpest tool in the shed, so there is that However, I did agree with the concept of separating Anastasia from Anna , but I did wish for a traditional type of dual timeline, without all that skipping around The novel s strongest area is the pacing and the agonizingly taut build up of suspense We must watch with mounting dread as the Romanov s are taken to Siberia, the clock ticking away as they careen towards their ultimate, tragic fate This part of the story is interwoven with Anna s as she sits in a German court waiting on their decision, hoping she will at long last lay legitimate and official claim to the name Anastasia Romanov The theories mapped out here are very imaginative, plausible, realistic and thought provoking I can tell the author put a great deal of thought and time into this novel, which is much appreciated Although it took me a long time to get through the book, really struggling with it at times, ultimately, I found it to be quite interesting and I m glad I didn t give up on it One point I think we can all agree on, no matter what, is that Anna s claims turned Anastasia Romanov into a legend, taking on a life of its own If not for her, Anastasia and her sisters would most likely have long been forgotten over time, along with other royal families who were met with the same fate Just a little something to ponder over I do recommend this book to anyone who enjoys Romanov history, of course, but be prepared this is not a fairy tale I would also recommend this book to anyone who enjoys historical fiction in general This book will most likely spark your curiosity about the Romanov family and you will want to learn about this them, and the events leading up to their capture, exile, and murders 4 stars

  2. says:

    This book, for me, was mediocre The history behind this story was fascinating, but the way the story was executed, was ill conceived There were two alternating story lines that were asynchronous to one another, which made for a pretty confusing reading experience However, with all that being said, I still really enjoyed the story and the history This novel chronicled the final days of the Romanov family, shining a light on Anastasia Did she die in Ekaterinburg with the rest of her family or didn t she That is what the author wants the reader to decide The other story follows a woman claiming to be Anastasia, who goes by Anna Anderson If you are interested in Russian history, I definitely think you would like this book I liked the story..I did I just thought it could have been better Written better Told better..Like Shania Twain says. That Don t Impress Me Much

  3. says:

    Once you eliminate the impossible, whatever remains, no matter how improbable, must be the truth Sir Arthur Conan DoyleMost people know the story of the execution assassination of Tsar Nicholas II and the rest of the Romanov family in Elakterinburg, Russia at the hands of the Bolsheviks following the Russian revolution Most have also heard of the woman Anna Anderson who claimed for years to be Anastasia Romanov and that she survived the brutal attack that claimed the lives of her family and servants This is a clever telling of that story The question about what whether Anastasia Romanov survived the firing squad in the basement has fascinated people for decades Lack of DNA testing and location of a grave burial site helped many who stepped forward to claim that she was the sole survivor Of course, through the passing of time, DNA testing has been conducted and grave site excavations have given a clear answer.But as the saying goesit s not the destination, it s the journey Lawhon takes the reader on a unique journey using two story lines While reading this book, readers will either enjoy or become annoyed by the storytelling While Anastasia Romanov s story is told chronologically, the story of Anna Anderson is told in reverse In Author s note, Ariel Lawhon states that the movie Memento is a favorite of hers This style of writing also reminded me of the book All the missing girls which was also told in reverse.I found that I rather liked how she told her story The storytelling was unique, granted, it did take me a couple of chapters to wrap my head around it Thankfully, the chapters are labeled with the time you are reading That is a big help There is a lot of historical detail in this book It is evident that the Author did a great deal of research prior to the writing of this book History buffs may detect that Lawhon blended several characters into one i.e had one character be a blending of 2 real life guards of the Romanov s in order to help the reader keep track of events and not be weighed down by too many characters It is hard to say too much without giving away spoilers, but this work of historical fiction was very good I really appreciated how she blended historical facts with fiction If you do not know the entire history about the Romanov s family s fall from grace and the events leading up to their execution, it is laid out for you here I highly recommend reading the Author s note at the end I think this is essential She details her research, why she blended characters, her inspiration for the reverse story telling and what lead her to write this book I was actually deciding between a 3.5 and a 4 star rating, and then I read the Author s note and that pushed the book to a 4 star rating for me.I love when books cause me to think, feel and also to learn I did learn some facts while reading this book and I found I often wanted to put the book down and think about what I had just read Mainly because things in this book really happened Sitting and thinking about the horrible treatment of this family especially the girls and what they endured living in constant fear and dread, I can t even imagine Again, interesting story telling and a compelling read Thank you to Doubleday books and NetGalley for providing me with an advanced readers copy of this book.See of my reviews at www.openbookpost.com

  4. says:

    i am absolutely obsessed with all things romanov i couldnt tell you how many times i watched the animated film anastasia as a girl and what i thought was just a childhood phase has slowly become something of a passion, so you can imagine my excitement when this book came out earlier this year.the story of anna anderson is not one that i am too familiar with i was aware there was someone who claimed to be the grand duchess anastasia, but beyond the claims eventually being dismissed, i knew nothing specific however, i think that enhanced my reading experience, as i didnt know what to expect and it gave the story a sense of mystery and although this book is right up my street, i couldnt help but feel a little let down i think the biggest disappointment was the method in which this story was told this book tells both annas and anastasias stories in a very nonlinear fashion anastasias is told chronologically beginning in 1917 and annas is told backwards starting in 1970 until the two stories converge and i understand why it was told this way unfortunately, what was meant to be alluring only lead to frustration the constant switching between the two was difficult to follow also, i was quite bored with annas story, which was half the book not particularly sure why that was, but i found myself skimming through her chapters just to get to anastasias regardless of my minor displeasures with this book, there was still a lot of new information that i learned this book was very well researched and i could tell a lot of time went into making it factually accurate i dont regret reading it, but i would only recommend it to those really interested in anna andersons story for those looking for other historical fiction novels about the romanovs final days, i would recommend the kitchen boy or the house of special purpose instead 3.5 stars

  5. says:

    4 engrossing stars to I Was Anastasia Being approved to read an early copy of I Was Anastasia was like winning the lottery to this historical fiction fan Not only because of my love for the genre, but also because of my interest in Anastasia Not because she was a princess necessarily, but because growing up I remember discussions about Anna Anderson and if she was or was not the real Anastasia Romanov Ariel Lawhon ambitiously tackles this notion in a genius structure through writing from two viewpoints in different timelines, Anastasia s in forward progression, and Anna s in reverse In the Author s Note, Lawhon describes that it was challenging to write this way, and I kept thinking that as I read She even read biographies of Anna Anderson in reverse order so that she would formulate it in her head the way she would eventually write Anna s voice It would have been easier to write in linear form, and perhaps easier for the reader to follow but I enjoyed this convergence in storylines It built the suspense for me Even though I already knew the true outcome, I longed for a different one as I quickly read through this book waiting for the timelines to intersect, waiting for the answer Lawhon would write Reading the Author s Note also inspired me to dig deeper into Romanov history I have a nonfiction book she cited as a reference, The Romanov Sisters The Lost Lives of the Daughters of Nicholas and Alexandra, and plan to read it soon to learn Thank you to Ariel Lawhon, Doubleday, and Netgalley for the ARC I Was Anastasia is available now

  6. says:

    Those unfamiliar with the Anastasia Romanov Anna Anderson story will find much to like in this fictional novel It s an effective introduction to the bizarre controversy surrounding two historical people My experience was a bit different As others have mentioned, Anastasia s story is told chronologically while Anna s story is told in reverse order Given that this is well worn material, I understand that the author chose this structure for dramatic effect However, I found it to be a contrivance that was annoying than dramatic Characters carry on conversations and you don t find out until one or chapters afterwards who some of these characters are which blurs the meaning of the initial conversations And then there are the characterizations which left me cold and I mean the kind of frigidity that one would find in, say, Siberia Granted, I was Anastasia is about the Anastasia Anna dispute but I have read other historical fiction that has handled the questions surrounding the violent tragedy of July 1917 deftly If upon reading this book you find that you are interested in the Romanov Dynasty, I would recommend anything written by Robert K Massie His narrative biographies are accessible and thorough providing the socio political background necessary to understand why events happened as they did Not a bad read but it didn t make me want to do cartwheels either.

  7. says:

    3.5 I am fairly familiar with the last days of the Romanovs, having read a few non fiction books about the subject The woman who appears and tries to prove that she is a Romanovs daughter Anastasia, I was less familiar In alternating chapters we follow both stories The one of the Romanovs imprisonmrnt and eventually murder is written in a linear timeline, the story of Anna is told backwards in time, even within the same Chapter, we go backwards.I did like learning about the girls personalities, though of course the focus is on Anastasia They went through some terrible things, even so because they had such a protected upbringing Quite heartbreaking that the children were blamed for their parents mistakes The part with Anna was also told well, but I found because of the way it was written, sometimes confusing.A great deal of research went into this novel, and the author explains in her authors note what that entailed and what she changed to make the story flow better She also explains why she wrote it the way she did I enjoyed this for the most part, but though I read why she wrote it this way, I still found myself liking those sections less.

  8. says:

    I adored this book It was cleverly constructed, expertly researched, deeply moving and I couldn t wait to get to it at the end of the day, which is when I read for pleasure Highly recommend, folks.

  9. says:

    3.5 stars view spoiler Even though I knew the story of The Romanovs and their fate, I knew very little about Anna Anderson who for decades claimed to be Anastasia Romanov and worked to prove that she survived the firing squad that took the lives of Tsar Nicholas II and his family I was pulled in at the beginning, but my interest in Anna s story waned Maybe it was because I knew the outcome even though I knew not much else about her There are dual narratives Anna s which moves backwards in time and Anastasia s in chronological order In the author s note, Ariel Lawhon relates her attraction to Anna s story but it was the Anastasia chapters that captivated me The imagined account of what it was like for the Romanov family in the time just before they are sent off to Siberia and their death was compelling I was so taken by the family in spite of what history tells us about Tsar Nicholas II Captivated enough that I now want to read about the Romanovs This time I ll try a non fiction account I was less taken with the Anna chapters and I found myself hurrying through those to get back to the Anastasia chapters I did though find the backward telling an interesting mechanism It took me a while to get used to it, but I liked the challenge in spite of my desire to get back to the Romanovs in 1917 Lawhon clarifies what she takes liberty with in the telling of the story, and I appreciate what appears to be a well researched account 3 stars but an extra half for the intrigue that has me wanting to read about the Romanovs I received an advanced copy of this book from Doubleday Books through NetGalley hide spoiler

  10. says:

    I admit to being endlessly fascinated with Romanov family history and with the woman who claimed to be Anastasia So apparently is Ariel Lawhon, as she weaves together both those stories in her latest work of historical fiction one, about the last tragic eighteen months of the Romanov family s lives told through the eyes of their youngest daughter and the second, about Anna Anderson who claimed to be Anastasia Anna s story is told backwards chronologically beginning with her last court case in 1970 and then regressing back through time what happened before that, and before that and so on Eventually the two stories come together and the reader sees why the author chose to tell her story in this manner It worked for me I know a few readers have said that they abandoned the book because of this frustrating chronological structure, which keeps the reader off balance, making it hard to grasp the plot and remember names and places But my advice is to stick with it it does get easier to understand and there s a payoff at the end Ariel Lawhon has done some fine writing here I thoroughly enjoyed spending time with both Annas This book may launch me on another Russian literature craze Thank you to NetGalley, the author and publisher Doubleday for granting me the opportunity to read an arc of this fascinating new book I am also grateful for receiving a hardcover copy through the Keep Turning Pages group giveaway.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I Was Anastasia download I Was Anastasia , read online I Was Anastasia , kindle ebook I Was Anastasia , I Was Anastasia 323b743e07e7 Countless Others Have Rendered Their Verdict Now It Is Your TurnRussia, July , Under Direct Orders From Vladimir Lenin, Bolshevik Secret Police Force Anastasia Romanov, Along With The Entire Imperial Family, Into A Damp Basement In Siberia Where They Face A Merciless Firing Squad None Survive At Least That Is What The Executioners Have Always Claimed Germany, February , A Young Woman Bearing An Uncanny Resemblance To Anastasia Romanov Is Pulled Shivering And Senseless From A Canal In Berlin Refusing To Explain Her Presence In The Freezing Water, She Is Taken To The Hospital Where An Examination Reveals That Her Body Is Riddled With Countless, Horrific Scars When She Finally Does Speak, This Frightened, Mysterious Woman Claims To Be The Russian Grand Duchess AnastasiaHer Detractors, Convinced That The Young Woman Is Only After The Immense Romanov Fortune, Insist On Calling Her By A Different Name Anna Anderson As Rumors Begin To Circulate Through European Society That The Youngest Romanov Daughter Has Survived The Massacre, Old Enemies And New Threats Are Awakened