[Epub] ➟ Economic Science and the Austrian Method By Hans-Hermann Hoppe – Saudionline.co.uk


10 thoughts on “Economic Science and the Austrian Method

  1. says:

    An integration of the aprioristic reasoning into the rationalist epistemology of social sciencies, for make it a case for a new rational realistic corpus This work shows how the praxeology is the economics, and the limits of social investigations gave by the a priori categories of causality and teleology There are too much logical propositions in a little book, you will enjoy it, you will realize what is human reality and knowledge with its logic discurse, but you will need to read it again.


  2. says:

    Absolutely one of the best reads on economic methodology and epistemology.


  3. says:

    A rather lackluster defence of a priori argumentation, and Rationalism in general, in the social sciences especially economics The argument is based on the praxeology of Mises, as developed in Human Action and elsewhere Passing references are made to Kant and Leibniz, but this is mostly lip service Passing references are made to other sciences than economics, but this is also mostly lip service A few embarrassingly superficial and disparaging comments are made to relativism in the social sciences, to set the scene for the Bad Guys.Hoppe is almost an orthodox follower of Mises, and there is nothing here that isn t already in the epistemology of Mises The author fails to justify the assumptions of Misesian rationalism, even though he makes it clear that these can be defended quite rigorously The result is a rigorous, foolproof defence of unjustifiable and unjustified assumptions, most notably the so called Action Axiom that humans act Based on a rather simplistic notion of human beings as teleological actors who make plans and carry them out, Hoppe derives the foundations of epistemology therefrom with a bit of Habermasian cream on top, with the added emphasis of argumentation and communication From these foundations, the economic science of Austrian economics is supposed to be derived somehow.I was left unconvinced of the idea that free market rent control theory can be derived a priori from the simple axiom that humans act It would be awesome if such a theory could be found, but the reader is left wanting The a priori theory demands incredibly strong foundations, and Mises Hoppe fail to provide such strong foundations at least in Hoppe s explanation , even though they are capable of drawing some good rational arguments based on these rather randomly chosen premises, which need further elaboration and expansion.Overall, Hoppe s strength and weakness lies in his almost anal retentive, point by point, rigorously autistic mode of argumentation It unfortunately crosses the line from rationally rigorous to blindly dogmatic the moment it grants a priori status to flimsy, dubious assumptions leading to a massive construction of logically foolproof but wholly unconvincing Summa Theologica of Austrian economics.


  4. says:

    The last chapter of Hoppe s book contains the following phrase In so establishing the place of praxeology proper, I have come full circle in outlining the system of rationalist philosophy as ultimately grounded in the action axiom It has been my goal here ro reaffirm Mises s claim that economics is praxeology that the case for praxeology is an indisputable one and that empiricist or historicist hermeneuticist interpretations of economics are self contradictory doctrines And it has been my objective to indicate that Misesian insight into the nature of praxeology also provides the very foundation on which traditional rationalist philosophy can be successfully reconstructed, and systematically integrated I very much believe that Hoppe s objective has been fulfilled, even though this 80 page essay may leave you unsatisfied on the apparent superficiality with which Hoppe deals with some subjects but the book has a lot of footnotes and further readings, which is obviously a plus It s, generally speaking, a great primer on the epistemology of economics from an Austrian perspective.


  5. says:

    As dry as anything you could ever read but it does give a substantial argument for the scientific method of praxeology This was better than Selgin s book on praxeology.


  6. says:

    Short but dense read A lot of good stuff though.


  7. says:

    The best exposition of the Austrian methodological framework hands down.


  8. says:

    Professor Hoppe s book focuses on two main theses The first thesis is that economic science and economics is a science is properly grounded in the deductive method, based on the incontestable axiom of action, explicitly laid down by the economist Ludwig von Mises Thus, the theorems of economics are true synthetic a priori propositions Having accepted Austrian economics myself, I find this thesis to be reasonable and uncontroversial.The second thesis is, for those who already accept the first, a bit interesting This thesis states that rationalist epistemology itself the rationalist philosophy of knowledge is properly grounded in the axioms of action and argument Hoppe shows rather convincingly that the two main competitors to rationalist epistemology, namely empiricism and historicism, are incoherent and self refuting Further, Hoppe shows how the axioms of action that human beings act and argument that human beings communicate and attempt to convince one another by argument enable the rationalist to avoid charges of idealism, to which Kant, for example, was vulnerable This grounding of epistemology in action and argument may seem surprising to some, but Hoppe s argument that it is through action that the mind interfaces with the external world is convincing.Incidentally, Hoppe s rationalist program seems to imply mathematical constructivism at least he approvingly cites Paul Lorenzen, a mathematical constructivist, though this is somewhat tangential to Hoppe s main arguments My main problem with mathematical constructivism is its denial of the Law of Excluded Middle that a proposition P is either true or false and nothing else though I suspect that constructivists might reply that G del s Incompleteness Theorem and its demonstration of unprovable theorems suggests that the constructivists denial of the Law of Excluded Middle is warranted But G del himself was not a constructivist he was a mathematical Platonist.As one might see from the above digression on the philosophy of mathematics, Professor Hoppe s book, though short, has a wealth of ideas to consider His writing is rather clear with one exception he tends to write sentences that are considerably long, too long for most people to follow naturally without rereading them or splitting them up mentally I found myself occasionally experiencing mental stack overflows, as it were, when reading some of Hoppe s longer sentences Here s an example of a particularly egregious one Recognizing, as we have just done, that knowledge claims are raised and decided upon in the course of argumentation and that this is undeniably so, one can now reconstruct the task of epistemology precisely as that of formulating those propositions which are argumentatively indisputable in that their truth is already implied in the very fact of making one s argument and so cannot be denied argumentatively and to delineate the range of such a priori knowledge from the realm of propositions whose validity cannot be established in this way but require additional, contingent information for their validation, or that cannot be validated at all and so are mere metaphysical statements in the pejorative sense of the term metaphysical.Fortunately, one can mentally refactor this sentence into a few separate sentences, and thereby it becomes digestible I suspect, though I am not certain, that perhaps these long sentences may have something to do with the fact that English is not Hoppe s first language that being German Aside from this, Professor Hoppe presents an intellectually stimulating discussion of the proper methodological grounding of economics and the proper grounding of epistemology This short volume packs a scintillating discussion on economics, metaphysics, epistemology, action, and argumentation It s worth reading whether you find yourself in complete agreement with Professor Hoppe or not.This book is available for free at the Ludwig von Mises Institute You can also buy a physical copy or Kindle version of it at .Professor Hoppe has also written other works that touch on the ideas in this book Intellectual Cover for Socialism In Defense of Extreme Rationalism Thoughts on Donald McCloskey s The Rhetoric of Economics Some of his other writings, though not dedicated to the ideas of this book, also contain discussions of these ideas.


  9. says:

    Great supplementary to Mises Ultimate Foundation of Economic Science In addition to elaborating Mises defense of praxeology, Hoppe also traces the philosophical tradition that Mises has based the praxeological system upon back to Immanuel Kant which Mises didn t mention himself in the other book mentioned , and builds upon his writings to add a second a priori axiom argumentation.


  10. says:

    If you want a coherent argument about epistemology in the social sciences, and specifically economics, this is an important document.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Economic Science and the Austrian Method summary pdf Economic Science and the Austrian Method, summary chapter 2 Economic Science and the Austrian Method, sparknotes Economic Science and the Austrian Method, Economic Science and the Austrian Method 7f091c0 A Definitive Defense Of The Praxeological View Economics As A Purely Deductive Science Hoppe Rests His Argument On The Kantian Idea Of The Synthetic Apriori Proposition, Thereby Expanding An Aim Of Mises S In The Methodology Section Of Human Action Hoppe Is The Austrian School S Most Prominent Methodologist, And Here He Is In Top Form

  • Paperback
  • 82 pages
  • Economic Science and the Austrian Method
  • Hans-Hermann Hoppe
  • English
  • 13 August 2018
  • 9780945466208

About the Author: Hans-Hermann Hoppe

Is a well-known author, some of his books are a fascination for readers like in the Economic Science and the Austrian Method book, this is one of the most wanted Hans-Hermann Hoppe author readers around the world.