[Reading] ➼ Conceived in Liberty (4 Volume Set) ➲ Murray N. Rothbard – Saudionline.co.uk


  • Hardcover
  • 1668 pages
  • Conceived in Liberty (4 Volume Set)
  • Murray N. Rothbard
  • 23 November 2019
  • 9780945466260

10 thoughts on “Conceived in Liberty (4 Volume Set)

  1. says:

    I see history as centrally a race and conflict between social power the productive consequence of voluntary interactions among men and state power In those eras of history when liberty social power has managed to race ahead of state power and control, the country and even mankind have flourished In those eras when state power has managed to catch up with or surpass social power, mankind suffers and declines Murray N Rothbard, Conceived in Liberty, Vol 1, p 10.The above quote pretty much sums up the approach Rothbard took in writing Conceived in Liberty The struggle between the liberty of the individual and the acquiring and concentration of powers into a group the state, a religion, or a company are the gory economic details that Rothbard elaborates on while other history books exclude This approach, of observing the flow of money and power provides a much insightful look at history The book also takes one through the evolution, formation, and realization of what individual liberty is Unfortunately, many back then, and many today, fail to see and comprehend this struggle between liberty and tyranny, and thus, I fear we will have to repeat the painful lessons of history rather than move forward and build a better world Volume One covers the discovery of the Americas and the colonies in the 17th century Volume Two covers the period of salutary neglect in the first half of the 18th century Volume Three covers the advance to revolution, from 1760 1775.Volume Four covers the political, military, and ideological history of the revolution and after.Liberty has always been threatened by the encroachments of power, power which seeks to suppress, control, cripple, tax, and exploit the fruits of liberty and production This struggle is raging today, and this book has many lessons in it to awaken and motivate us today to continue to fight for liberty.


  2. says:

    I greatly enjoyed reading this book which was the first book length or in this case, multi volume book length I ve ever read on the Revolutionary period in American history The work is extremely enlightening and Rohtbard s characteristic writing style and his frankness about who the good guys are makes the work highly readable The work is also interesting as Rothbard clearly views the Revolution from the standpoint of how a libertarian revolution might happen which tactics of revolution are most effective and which consistent with libertarian theory A must for anyone interested in libertarianism or in libertarian interpretations of history.


  3. says:

    I read this the second year I was out here in Portland 2007 , having been able to get each volume from different libraries through interlibrary loan The straightforward style, easily accessible to non historians, engages and explores one of the interesting eras of the early colonization of the eastern seaboard of North America.


  4. says:

    Interesting history of the fight for human freedom from the 1400 s to the late 1700 s in colonial North America A documentation of the fight from escaping the old world order represented by the enslavement of people by England at the time and the New World Order represented by freedom in America Interesting to note the same type of parallels went on back then that we face today Monopoly capitalism, corporate cronyism, usurpation of man s natural rights to be free, government corruption and human sacrifice Unfortunately today, and not just in America, we see a modern day New World Order, which is really the Old World Order of the British Empire rearing its ugly head once again just on a sinister scale through the utilization of technology and fractional reserve banking to bankrupt and control a once free people The struggle for human freedom and individual rights and private property will always be just that as the American Revolution demonstrated as we continue battling against the ongoing attempts of our enslavement by the corporatist elite and the government threat that wants to eliminate our way of life as a free and sovereign people by discrediting the Declaration of Independence, tearing up the U.S Constitution and Bill of Rights as we represent a threat to their power and profits.


  5. says:

    Rothbard is most famous or infamous as a political philosopher, for such works as For a New Liberty The Libertarian Manifesto It would be easy enough to dismiss his work as a historian out of hand for this reason, but I think that would be a huge mistake When I got Conceived in Liberty, I, too, thought it would be a narrative, perhaps a truthful one, certainly one from a valuable perspective, but still a narrative Narratives are all well and good, but they don t substitute for learning the actual facts and events.I was pleasantly surprised, then, that Rothbard didn t just write a narrative This is a bona fide historical textbook series of textbooks, really , one that painstakingly describes events, quotes witnesses and letters, mentions statistics, and so on Some impressive sourcework went into it, too, both of primary and secondary sources Rothbard presents nothing less than a very thorough and very detailed reconstruction of some 250 years of American history He gives dates, places, names, all you could ask for in a textbook He relates the individual battles of the American Revolution, that time Pennsylvania was without an effective government for seven years, Benjamin Franklins sheer numberless acts of opportunism such as drawing up the Mutiny Act of 1765 , the Great Awakening , the Green Mountain Boys, the Regulators and the Sons of Liberty, and a good hundred events and people.Of course, Rothbard, being the stereotypical libertarian, talks from a libertarian perspective I have no doubt his bias sometimes got the better of him, that he didn t relay all the nuances there were to some of the statist characters he describes, or importantly that he got too euphemistic over such types as John Wilkes, and hence wouldn t see their shortcomings That is to be expected in any history book, and at least Rothbard is open about possible biases Most importantly, his history is so detailed that it should be easy enough to disprove him if he got something wrong, or even to disagree with parts of his overall narrative based on the text itself So, no harm done.What I particularly liked was that he was capable of grasping religious motivations I know of surprisingly few authors who are capable of doing so, even among professional historians, yet surprisingly, Rothbard an agnostic, I believe pulled it off He doesn t fall into clich s, either While his sympathies obviously lie with the Quakers, he does acknowledge that at some point, they lost their pacifistic ways And as a Catholic, I was particularly glad that he both acknowledged that Maryland was very tolerant when it had a Catholic majority, and that the American Revolution was partially sparked by anti Catholicism Speaking of religion, here is one of Rothbards hottest takes The Salem Witch Trials had nothing to do with religion, and everything to do with politics They targetted political enemies, and ended as soon as the prosecutors themselves were named by witnesses Religion did play a role, but only as a spurious excuse As for what I got out of this book, that is a bit hard to say, simply because of its scope For me, it s the only textbook on early American history that I am going to need for perhaps a few years to come Not because it is that good, but because I plan to specialize in other periods, like the Middle Ages in general and the Crusades in particular, or early Church history If I ever decide to read up on American history, then I am convinced that bConceived in Liberty will provide me with an excellent foundation to build on.


  6. says:

    Wonderful book It took two years, and several gaps, to have completed all three volumes of Rothbard s magisterial, worthwhile, beautifully written, if incomplete, history of colonial America and the fine libertarian Revolution.Some observations 1 Rothbard s fervor for the libertarian revolutionary spirit leads him to join the classical liberals of old in favoring the French Revolution, long condemned by American libertarians and conservatives as preceding the SJW hysterics and the leftist corruption of modern Western globalism He interprets the American Revolution as radical He sees the Enlightenment as a generally fine movement for the cause of Liberty In this he is joined by Chesterton and Belloc, staunch Catholics who favored the French Revolution, and Robert R Palmer, whose work strongly influenced the fourth volume of Rothbard s history 2 Rothbard s conflict theory, of Liberty against power, is quite convincing I imagine how it could be applied to the times of the Renaissance, classical Athens and Rome, Great Britain 3 Rothbard was no worshipper of democracy, yet unlike Hoppe, Rothbard saw democracy as neutral insofar as it was merely a pattern of voting He argued against the opposition between liberty and democracy, at least in the context of the history books, and argues that, far from being mere mob rule, democracy went hand in hand with the libertarian cause of the American Revolution 4 It s well written, dense sometimes I skimmed over, missing important facts, but I feel like I got the general feel and sweep of the work 5 Perhaps my favorite of the volumes was Volumes III and IV, perhaps because they center and around the American Revolution than the first two.I also appreciated the bon mots about Charles Lee, John Milton, Roger Williams, Samuel Adams, Patrick Henry, Thomas Jefferson, John Locke, Voltaire, and even Rousseau.


  7. says:

    Extremely detailed account of early American history and its significance to an anarcho capitalist theorist.


  8. says:

    Available from


  9. says:

    If you count the bibliographical essays, this work is about 1,575 densely spaced pages long in hardcover I ve made several attempts to read it, and I always ended up abandoning it it was a long time before I was finally able to stick with it and finish it Now that I finally have, I m extremely glad to have done so.The first volume, the longest in the series, deals with the history of the American colonies from Columbus through the end of the seventeenth century This volume is primarily a religious and economic history of the colonies, but there are some fascinating political tidbits as well, such as the fact that Pennsylvania was essentially anarchist for a significant period of time.The second volume deals with the period of salutary neglect during the first half of the eighteenth century At this point, the colonies are or less fully established, but serious British repression had not yet begun After struggling with the first volume, this is where the narrative really grabbed me the political situation gets interesting here, and familiar figures such as Benjamin Franklin and George Washington begin to filter into the narrative.The third volume is probably the best of the four The pace of the narrative picks up significantly as salutary neglect gives way to British imposed mercantilism, establishing the grievances that will inexorably lead to the revolution Here, Rothbard is on fire, providing extensive insight into the political forces and factions at play here and the various philosophies, ideologies, pecuniary interests, and power struggles behind them.The fourth volume deals with the period of the war for the revolution, picking up immediately after Lexington Concord and ending just before the Constitutional Convention and the French Revolution This volume alternates between military and political history Rothbard lays great emphasis on the tensions between guerrilla warfare and conventional warfare some American military leaders Nathaniel Greene, Daniel Morgan readily understood the former, while others George Washington were cluelessly and stubbornly insistent on the latter On the political side, a significant amount of attention is given to the exploitation and oppression of the Tories Loyalists , who are also shown to have been enemy combatants significantly figuring into late British counter revolutionary military strategy Rothbard also details the typically disastrous history of wartime inflation actually hyperinflation and price controls, and the extent to which they actually damaged the radical cause, empowering a conservative counter revolution epitomized by Robert Morris s otherwise inexplicable rise to power The fourth volume concludes with a discussion of the revolution s impact overseas the American example triggered a wave of rebellions in Europe, ultimately culminating in the French Revolution.Rothbard is delightfully frank, and always anxious to puncture the over inflated reputations of historical figures he considers overrated Benjamin Franklin was an opportunistic hedonist George Washington was vain and incompetent Robert Morris was a Mephistophelian usurper and embezzler These are the extreme examples most figures come in for a moderate revision, sometimes positive and sometimes negative The point is that Rothbard insists on applying his own independent judgement, even when that requires him to discard the consensus of most historians.And why shouldn t he As Rothbard shows convincingly, the historical consensus has gotten the revolution wrong on a number of points, from the importance of guerrilla warfare which, surprisingly, was not appreciated until about the late 1960s , to the American populace s broad support of the revolution, to the revolution s radical and internal not just external character Rothbard s work has overcome my skepticism and convinced me that the American Revolution was in fact an explicitly and ideologically libertarian revolution I read the four volume edition hardback with red cloth binding published by the Mises Institute, which is of outstanding physical quality and durability As a rule, all books published by the Mises Institute are extremely well made This version has now gone out of print, replaced by a single volume edition I haven t seen this edition, but I know from my experience with The Invisibles that there s no reading a 1,600 page hardcover comfortably I also listened to much of the audiobook Dr Floy Lilley s efforts in narrating the 80 hour book are heroic, but unfortunately also somewhat amateurish.


  10. says:

    This book goes into great details surrounding the founding of the United States There are numerous stories and pieces of history well before the revolution that most won t know about or hear in your college History classes This book is great addition to anyone studying the history of the U.S or for anyone who wants to understand why our form of government was so radical and new in 1776 I highly recommend this book to any patriotic Americans or those looking for details on why we formed the U.S.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Conceived in Liberty (4 Volume Set)characters Conceived in Liberty (4 Volume Set), audiobook Conceived in Liberty (4 Volume Set), files book Conceived in Liberty (4 Volume Set), today Conceived in Liberty (4 Volume Set), Conceived in Liberty (4 Volume Set) 4d0af For Anyone Who Thinks Of Murray Rothbard As Only A Economictheorist Or Political Thinker, These Four Spectacular Volumes Are Nothingshort Of Shocking They Offer A Complete History Of The Colonial Period OfAmerican History, A Period Lost To Students Today, Who Are Led To BelieveAmerican History Begins With The US Constitution Rothbard S Ambition Was To Shed New Light On Colonial History And Show That The Struggle For Human Liberty Was The Heart And Soul Of This Land From Its Discovery Through The Culminating Event Of The American Revolution These Volumes Are A Tour De Force, Enough To Establish Rothbard As One Of The Great American Historians Although A Detailed Narrative History Of The Struggle Between Liberty Andpower, Rothbard Offers A Third Alternative To The Conventional Interpretivedevices Against Those On The Right Who See The American Revolution As A Conservative Event, And Those On The Left Who Want To Invoke It As Somesort Of Proto Socialist Uprising, Rothbard Views This Period As A Time Ofaccelerating Libertarian Radicalism Through This Prism, Rothbardilluminates Events As Never Before The Volumes Were Brought Out In The S, But The Odd Timing And Unevendistribution Prevented Any Kind Of Large Audience They Were Beloved Only By A Few Specialists, And Sought After By Many Thanks To Their Outstandingreputation The Mises Institute Is Pleased To Be The Publisher Of The Newlyavailable Set Volume One Covers The Discovery Of The Americas And The Colonies In The Th CenturyPages, Including Index Volume Two Covers The Period Of Salutary Neglect In The First Half Of Theth CenturyPages, Including Index Volume Three Covers The Advance To Revolution, FromPages, Including Index Volume Four Covers The Political, Military, And Ideological History Of Therevolution And AfterPages, Including Index ABOUT THE AUTHOR Murray N Rothbard Distinguished Himself As An Economist, Writing A Major Treatise On Theory, Several Important Economic Histories, And A Highly Praised History Of Economic Thought But He Was Also Known As The Pioneer Thinker Of Libertarianism, The Political Philosophy That Roots Freedom In Private Property Ownership And Decries The State As Inherently Contrary To The Ethics Of A Free Society Writing From This Perspective, He Gained A Reputation As The Most Provocative And Influential Contributor To The Anarchist Tradition In Our Century


About the Author: Murray N. Rothbard

Murray Newton Rothbard was an influential American historian, natural law theorist and economist of the Austrian School who helped define modern libertarianism Rothbard took the Austrian School s emphasis on spontaneous order and condemnation of central planning to an individualist anarchist conclusion, which he termed anarcho capitalism.